Research & resources

Why a bop bag belongs in the playroom

What the play therapy literature says, and doesn’t say, about bop bags. Written for clinicians, students and anyone choosing playroom materials, with every source linked.

Four kinds of evidence

Claims about toys are often blurred together. On this page we keep them apart:

Theory about choosing materialsWhy play therapists include a bop bag at all.
What experienced clinicians reportExpert interviews and case experience. Valuable, but opinion rather than measurement.
Observations of how children use itStudies that record what children actually do with a Bobo.
Evidence about Brandy’s BOA itselfThere is no published research on our product. What we have is the professional endorsement of people who use it.
Theory

“Selected, not collected”

In child-centered play therapy, toys are children’s words and play is their language. The University of North Texas Center for Play Therapy summarizes Garry Landreth’s guidance: toys and materials should be selected, not collected, and chosen for a variety of expression, durability, and the chance to test limits safely.

UNT lists “Bobo or the bop bag” among its aggressive-release toys, alongside real-life and creative-expression toys. That category is honest about one use. In practice, a bop bag is also one of the few playroom materials a child can hug, lean on, care for and pretend with, because it stands at a child’s height and rights itself.

Source: UNT Center for Play Therapy, Toys and materials, citing Landreth (2002), p. 133.

Clinician experience

Do children only hit it?

In A Place for Bobo in Play Therapy (2003), Kay Trotter, Deborah Eshelman and Garry Landreth reviewed the debate about aggressive toys and interviewed four child-centered play therapists who train and supervise others: Garry Landreth, Jennifer Baggerly, Daniel Sweeney and Louise Guerney.

They described children who pat, feed, doctor, dress and talk to the Bobo as readily as they hit it. One child arrived on a cold morning, took off his coat and zipped it onto the Bobo. Dr. Landreth estimated that in most play therapy sessions children don’t act aggressively toward the Bobo at all.

“I have had many children treat the Bobo with great affection.”
Garry Landreth, interviewed in Trotter, Eshelman & Landreth (2003)

The interviewees also stressed that the toy isn’t what makes the difference. What matters is the relationship, and how the therapist reflects feelings and sets limits.

Source: Trotter, K., Eshelman, D., & Landreth, G. (2003). A place for Bobo in play therapy. International Journal of Play Therapy, 12(1), 117–139. doi.org/10.1037/h0088875. This is expert opinion and case experience, not a measured study.

Child-centered play therapy

A full vocabulary for play

Child-centered play therapy starts from a simple idea: play is a child’s language, and toys are the child’s words. Children who can’t yet put big feelings into speech can show them through what they do with the materials in the room.

If toys are words, a child needs a full vocabulary. Trotter, Eshelman and Landreth make the point both ways: a playroom stocked only with soft, cute toys tells a child that angry feelings don’t belong there, and a room with only aggressive toys leaves no way to show tenderness or care. The same bop bag can be hugged, fed, doctored, ridden or pushed, so it serves both sides of that vocabulary.

We would never tell an adult in therapy, “We don’t talk about that here.”

Dr. Landreth used that comparison when he was asked about zero-tolerance policies. Refusing to allow any aggressive play in therapy, he said, would be like telling an adult client they have a lot of anger but can’t talk about it. From this point of view, removing aggressive toys from the playroom altogether, as Athena Drewes recommended, can tell a child the same thing: some feelings aren’t welcome here.

Accepting feelings, limiting behavior

Welcoming every feeling doesn’t mean anything goes. In child-centered play therapy, children may express any feeling through words and play, but therapists set limits that protect the child, the therapist and the room. A child may not hit the therapist, for example, but may pound the bop bag. The limit is set calmly, the feeling behind it is acknowledged, and the child is offered an acceptable way to show it.

The therapists interviewed by Trotter and colleagues stress that the toy alone doesn’t do the therapeutic work. It is the child’s experience of expressing a feeling with an accepting, understanding adult present that helps the child make sense of it. Dr. Landreth also noted that he knew of no research showing that hitting the Bobo in the playroom leads to more aggression outside it, and described case reports in which children became less aggressive outside the playroom. Those are clinical observations, not controlled studies, and we present them that way.

Source: Trotter, K., Eshelman, D., & Landreth, G. (2003). A place for Bobo in play therapy. International Journal of Play Therapy, 12(1), 117–139. doi.org/10.1037/h0088875. See also Landreth, G. Play Therapy: The Art of the Relationship. Routledge.

Another approach

How Synergetic Play Therapy sees it

Lisa Dion, founder of Synergetic Play Therapy, notes that bop bags are debated in the field. Many children use them to project feelings of being powerless or powerful. Others lean or rest on them, or bounce and roll on them. She cautions therapists against reflections that encourage aggression, such as “hit him again,” and puts the therapist’s own steadiness at the center of intense moments.

Source: Lisa Dion, Bop bags in the playroom, Synergetic Play Therapy Institute.

The other side

Why some clinicians disagree

Not everyone agrees that a Bobo belongs in the playroom. As summarized in the 2003 article, some writers have argued that a Bobo invites aggressive behavior and could teach it. Athena Drewes described a case in which a child’s aggressive play with the Bobo carried over outside the playroom, and recommended other expressive materials such as clay, water, drawing and stories.

We think therapists choosing materials deserve the whole picture. That’s also why we don’t claim a bop bag “releases” anger or reduces aggression on its own. What a child does with it, and what it means, depends on the child and the therapeutic relationship.

Limits

What we don’t know

Further reading

Shop the BOARead the endorsements
From $210Shop the BOA